Why lenders value your repayment history over your salary: Experts weigh in

You might believe that a fat pay slip is your golden ticket to a loan. But here is a surprise, your bank cares more about how you have been paying your old bills than how much you earn today. Here is why:

Salary shows ability, whereas history shows habit

Your salary tells a lender what you can do, whereas your repayment history tells them what you actually do.

Simranjeet Singh, CEO – SME & Retail Business, Anand Rathi Global Finance, says, "While stated salary or income reflects the borrower's ability to pay on paper, it is vulnerable to sudden challenges like job loss, economic factors and volatility. In comparison to this, the borrower's repayment history is a time-tested financial discipline across varied conditions which showcases the borrower's financial habits in terms of budgeting, cash-flow management, and willingness to honor commitments."

Think about it this way. A person earning ₹2 lakh a month but regularly missing EMIs is a bigger risk than someone earning ₹60,000 who never misses a payment. A salary can change overnight; a layoff, a medical emergency, or a business slowdown can wipe it out. But the habit of paying on time? That is built over the years and tells a much deeper story.

One missed payment can change everything

Credit bureaus like CIBIL, Experian, and CRIF track every payment you make, or miss, sometimes going back several years, and the data they hold is eye-opening.

Simranjeet Singh further points out, “Even a single DPD instance in the borrower's repayment track exhibits almost more than 100% probability of delinquency regardless of their income level.”

DPD simply means ‘Days Past Due’, the number of days you were late on a payment. Even one such mark raises serious red flags for lenders. A 30-day delay on a home loan EMI three years ago can still affect your loan approval today.

Furthermore, bad loans are not just a low-income problem. Singh notes that “NPAs are far higher in individuals with irregular repayment track records and frequent bounces.” In simple terms, NPA means a loan that has stopped being repaid, and lenders have seen enough cases to know that a high salary is no guarantee of timely repayment.

Behaviour over bank balance

Adhil Shetty, CEO of BankBazaar, frames it well: "Income tells lenders what you earn, but repayment history reveals who you are as a borrower."

“A borrower who reliably meets obligations through different financial seasons presents a fundamentally lower risk than someone earning well but carrying a patchy history, making past behaviour the most honest signal,” he adds.

This is why two people with the same salary can get very different loan offers. The one with a clean repayment record may get a lower interest rate, a higher loan amount, and faster approval. The other may face rejection or stricter terms, simply because of past payment behaviour.

What shows up on your credit report

Your credit report is not just about loans. It captures:

• Credit card bill payments
• Personal, home, and car loan EMIs
• Missed or late payments
• Loan settlements (where you paid less than what was owed)
• How often lenders have checked your credit (called hard enquiries)

Each of these shapes how a lender sees you, sometimes more than your current salary does.

Your income opens doors, and your repayment history decides if you walk through them. Lenders are not just asking "Can this person afford to repay?" They are asking, "Will this person repay?" And the only honest answer to that question lives in your past behaviour, not your current pay slip. Start treating every EMI date like a non-negotiable appointment, and your future loan approvals depend on it.

Disclaimer: MintMoney has a tie-up with fintechs for providing credit; you will need to share your information if you apply. These tie-ups do not influence our editorial content. This article only intends to educate and spread awareness about credit needs like loans, credit cards and credit score. MintMoney does not promote or encourage taking credit, as it comes with a set of risks, such as high interest rates, hidden charges, etc. We advise investors to discuss with certified experts before taking any credit.

To apply for instant loans upto ₹5 lakh, visit here